Skip to main content

Escalation and Resolving Disagreements

ISS employees should raise concerns and ask for help before an issue becomes larger.

Escalation is a normal part of working together. It allows the right people to become involved when additional knowledge, authority, coordination, or support is needed.

Escalation is collaboration, not failure.

Escalation does not automatically mean that someone has done something wrong or is wrong. It is a structured way to move an issue to the appropriate level when it cannot be resolved effectively at the current level. 

Escalate at the Lowest Appropriate Level

Issues should normally be addressed at the lowest reasonable level first.

The standard ISS escalation path is:

Person → Immediate Manager(s) → CITO → Vice President

For matters that are appropriately handled as Human Resources issues, the escalation path is:

Person → Immediate Manager(s) → CITO → Human Resources

For HR matters, Human Resources serves as the final escalation point instead of the Vice President.

Employees should not normally skip levels simply because they disagree with the answer received. Each level should have a reasonable opportunity to understand and address the issue.

Some circumstances may require a different reporting process under College policy or law. Employees should use the appropriate College process when applicable.

Work and Ticket Escalation

Work should be escalated when additional assistance, authority, or coordination is needed to move it forward.

When work cannot be resolved at the current level, employees should first involve the appropriate person or technical resource, then the immediate manager or managers when additional coordination, prioritization, or authority is needed. Matters requiring broader departmental authority should be escalated to the CITO.

Examples include situations where:

  • A ticket or issue is beyond the employee's knowledge, access, or authority.

  • The customer impact is greater than originally understood.

  • A deadline or customer commitment is at risk.

  • A service issue may actually be a broader outage or degradation.

  • Another ISS team must become involved.

  • A vendor or outside party is preventing progress.

  • Additional resources or management direction are needed.

  • The priority of the work may need to change.

  • The customer requests management involvement.

  • The employee has made reasonable progress but the work has become stalled.

Employees should escalate early enough for others to help.

Waiting until a deadline has already passed, a customer is significantly frustrated, or a service has been affected limits the team's ability to respond.

Escalation Does Not End Ownership

Escalating work does not mean simply handing the problem to someone else and walking away.

The employee should provide enough information for the next person to understand:

  • What the issue is.

  • Who or what is affected.

  • What has already been attempted.

  • What has been learned.

  • What decisions or assistance are needed.

  • What deadlines or customer commitments exist.

  • What the employee believes should happen next, when appropriate.

The employee should remain engaged until ownership has been clearly transferred or the employee is told otherwise.

Ticket notes, project artifacts, incident records, or other appropriate documentation should be updated so that the escalation does not depend only on a private conversation.

For additional guidance on work classification, ticket priority, outages, and handoffs, see Service Management, Operations, and Documentation.

Disagreements Between Team Members

Professional disagreement is normal.

ISS employees are encouraged to ask questions, offer alternatives, challenge assumptions, and raise concerns. Different perspectives can improve decisions when disagreements are handled professionally.

When two employees disagree, the first step should normally be to talk directly with one another.

Employees should:

  • Explain the concern clearly.

  • Listen to the other person's perspective.

  • Focus on the work, decision, behavior, or issue rather than the individual.

  • Look for areas of agreement.

  • Try to identify a reasonable solution.

  • Avoid personal attacks, raised voices, threats, intimidation, or disrespectful behavior.

The goal is not necessarily for everyone to agree. The goal is to understand the issue well enough to move the work forward professionally.

Escalating an Unresolved Disagreement

If employees cannot resolve the issue directly, the matter should be escalated to the appropriate immediate manager or managers.

When employees report to different managers, both managers may need to participate.

Managers should help:

  • Clarify responsibilities.

  • Clarify priorities.

  • Identify applicable procedures or standards.

  • Resolve conflicting direction.

  • Determine who has decision authority.

  • Establish the next action.

  • Address communication or conduct concerns when appropriate.

If the immediate manager or managers cannot resolve the issue, it should be escalated to the CITO.

If the issue remains unresolved after CITO review and further escalation is needed, it should be escalated to the Vice President.

If the matter is an HR issue, Human Resources is the final escalation point instead of the Vice President.

Disagreement With a Manager

Employees may professionally disagree with their manager.

The employee should normally discuss the concern directly with the manager first and provide any information the employee believes should be considered.

If the concern cannot be resolved at that level, the employee may escalate through the normal path:

Immediate Manager → CITO → Vice President

For an HR matter:

Immediate Manager → CITO → Human Resources

Once a decision has been made by the appropriate authority, employees are expected to follow reasonable direction unless there is a legitimate legal, safety, security, ethical, or College-policy concern that requires further escalation. 

Leaders are expected to make the best decision for the College based on the information available to them. They may not always be able to share all of the information informing a decision especially when confidential or sensitive information is involved.

Customer Escalation

Customers may also ask that an issue be escalated.

Employees should not discourage a customer from requesting management involvement.

When a customer requests escalation:

  • Remain professional.

  • Notify the appropriate manager.

  • Make sure the ticket or other record contains an accurate history of the issue.

  • Include actions already taken and any commitments already made.

  • Avoid becoming defensive or treating the escalation as a complaint against an individual.

Customer escalation is an opportunity to make sure the concern is being addressed at the appropriate level.

Escalate Early

Employees should not wait for a situation to become a crisis before asking for help.

Early escalation may allow the department to:

  • Reprioritize work.

  • Add technical resources.

  • Adjust a deadline.

  • Communicate with a customer.

  • Involve a vendor.

  • Obtain management approval.

  • Resolve a disagreement.

  • Prevent an outage.

  • Reduce risk.

A problem that is communicated early is usually easier to manage than one that is discovered after a commitment has already been missed.

Document Important Escalations

Significant work-related escalations should be documented in the appropriate authoritative record.

Depending on the situation, that may include:

  • A ticket

  • A project record

  • An incident record

  • A maintenance record

  • A status report

  • Other appropriate documentation

Interpersonal or personnel matters should be documented and handled with appropriate discretion.

Private or sensitive personnel information should not be placed in normal operational records.

Connection to Our Values

People Matter because disagreements and difficult situations should be handled with respect for the people involved.

Inclusiveness Matters because employees should be able to raise concerns, offer different perspectives, and challenge ideas professionally.

Communication Matters because unresolved issues rarely improve when people stop talking about them.

Integrity Matters because employees should raise concerns honestly, follow the appropriate escalation path, and accurately represent the situation.

Excellence Matters because timely escalation helps ISS solve problems, protect services, improve decisions, and support the College effectively.